top of page

Insanity and Postpartum Psychosis: Women Who Kill Their Children


Postpartum psychosis, insanity, and filicide.
Postpartum psychosis, insanity, and filicide.

The journey of motherhood, commonly perceived as an enriching and joyful experience, can sometimes take a dark and devastating turn for some women. Postpartum psychosis, a rare but severe mental health condition that can develop following childbirth, has the potential to lead a mother to commit unthinkable acts, including harm to her own child. In the most tragic cases, this could manifest as maternal filicide, that is, the act of a mother killing her child. Michele Davidson, an expert on postpartum psychosis and board member of Postpartum Support International, shared that around 5% of mothers dealing with postpartum psychosis may try to take their own lives, and about 4% might harm their babies.


Understanding Postpartum Psychosis

Postpartum psychosis, a rare and severe psychiatric disorder, manifests within days or weeks after childbirth. Manifesting in approximately 1-2 per 1000 deliveries, its profound impact can lead some women to commit unthinkable acts, such as killing their own children, a phenomenon known as maternal filicide. This article delves into the heart-wrenching issue of postpartum psychosis-induced insanity, shedding light on this complicated and devastating condition.


At its core, postpartum psychosis is characterized by a loss of contact with reality, with symptoms often including delusions (false beliefs), hallucinations (seeing or hearing things that aren't there), and severe confusion. Other symptoms can range from high mood (mania), characterized by feeling elated, talking too much, and feeling full of energy, to low mood, such as depression, anxiety, or lethargy. In some cases, a woman with postpartum psychosis may act erratically or display unusual behavior that is out of character.


The exact causes of postpartum psychosis are unclear, but it's likely linked to the dramatic hormonal changes during and after childbirth. Women with a history of bipolar disorder or schizoaffective disorder are at significantly increased risk, as are those who have previously suffered from postpartum psychosis. But it's crucial to note that the condition can also occur in women without any previous history of mental health issues.


Understanding Insanity

The concept of insanity in the context of these acts is complex. Legal definitions of insanity vary, but many involve a person's inability to understand their actions' nature and quality or distinguish right from wrong. In many cases of postpartum psychosis-induced filicide, the women, in their psychotic state, fail to grasp the true reality of their actions.


The complexity of insanity lies not just in its clinical definition but also its legal interpretation. Legally, insanity is often understood as the inability to understand the nature and consequences of one's actions or to differentiate right from wrong. Many women who commit filicide under the grip of postpartum psychosis may fulfill these criteria, deeply entangled in delusions that make their horrifying actions seem not just rational but necessary.


An Unavoidable Reality?

While it is a deeply unsettling subject, maternal filicide associated with postpartum psychosis is not an unavoidable reality. Multiple factors contribute to this tragic act, such as a lack of social support, a history of mental illness, or an inability to access appropriate mental health care. Therefore, a multi-faceted approach involving medical intervention, mental health education, and societal change is needed.


The relationship between postpartum psychosis and maternal filicide is not direct or inevitable. Several factors may push a woman over the precipice, such as a lack of social support, personal or family history of mental illness, previous traumatic experiences, and other stressors.


Cultural and societal factors also play a crucial role. Many societies place enormous pressure on women to embody an idealized vision of motherhood that may be unreachable, especially for those battling severe mental health issues. This pressure, coupled with the stigma around mental health and motherhood, can prevent women from seeking help when they need it most.


Treatment and Prevention

Prevention and treatment of postpartum psychosis and, by extension, its potential tragic consequences, such as maternal filicide, involve a multi-faceted approach that addresses mental health screening, appropriate medical care, social support, and societal attitudes.

  1. Mental Health Screening: This is the first line of defense in preventing postpartum psychosis. Mental health screenings should be a routine part of prenatal and postnatal care. Early detection of potential risk factors and symptoms can allow for early intervention, significantly reducing the risk of psychosis.

  2. Appropriate Medical Care: For women diagnosed with postpartum psychosis, immediate treatment is crucial. This typically involves a combination of medication and psychological therapy. Depending on the severity of the symptoms, hospitalization may be necessary. If a woman has a history of postpartum psychosis or bipolar disorder, she might be advised to start preventive treatment immediately after delivery or even during pregnancy.

  3. Social Support: Robust support systems for new mothers are essential. This can take the form of professional mental health services, support groups, community health resources, and strong networks of family and friends. New mothers, especially those at risk, should never feel like they are going through this alone.

  4. Societal Attitudes: Society plays a pivotal role in prevention. Society needs to encourage open discussions about mental health issues and promote understanding and acceptance. When mental health is stigmatized, it prevents those struggling from seeking help.

  5. Education: Education of all prospective parents, families, and healthcare professionals about the risks and signs of postpartum psychosis is critical. This could ensure early intervention and prevent the escalation of the condition.

  6. Access to Healthcare Services: Accessibility to prenatal and postnatal care services, especially mental health services, is crucial. These services should be affordable and available to all, irrespective of their economic status.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the intersection of insanity, postpartum psychosis, and maternal filicide is a deeply complex one, rooted in the intricacies of mental health, societal norms, and legal definitions. By striving for a society that champions mental health, promotes understanding, and provides support, it is possible to mitigate these tragedies' risk. The women who find themselves in this harrowing situation are not monsters but victims of a severe and devastating illness that, with the right treatment and support, can be managed effectively.


Authored by

Forensic Psychologist, Benjamin Silber, Ph.D., ABPP and Savera Mushtaq
Forensic Psychologist, Benjamin Silber, Ph.D., ABPP and Savera Mushtaq



Recent Posts

See All

1 Comment


Austin
Austin
Apr 09

It's truly heartbreaking to hear about cases involving postpartum psychosis leading to such tragic outcomes. It's crucial for society to offer support and understanding to women who may be struggling with mental health issues after childbirth. Seeking professional help and having open discussions about mental health can make a significant difference. On a slightly different note, if anyone is considering breast augmentation Dubai, it's essential to prioritize finding a surgeon like Dr. Leonard who prioritizes natural-looking results and understands the importance of enhancing confidence and self-esteem through their work.

Like
bottom of page