I personally grew up watching shows such as: Bones, Monk, Criminal Minds and many more. This massively sparked my interest in forensic science and psychology. However, do you think that the unrealistic depictions sometimes do more to damage these subjects than they do to encourage people to study them? Do you think that psychological profiles are as accurate as they seem and are reliable in criminal cases?
top of page
To see this working, head to your live site.
Forensic science and psychological profiles in TV
Forensic science and psychological profiles in TV
6 comments
Like
6 Comments
bottom of page
First let me say you have great taste. I love Spencer Reid, legend. Criminal Minds I loved.
In all of these shows there is one crucial thing missing about forensic psychology...the tedious bits. It's not surprising really, no one watches a show to watch a realistic depiction of any job. No one wants to see a forensic psychologist in their office filling out paperwork which is a huge part of the job, or even suppling questionnaires and so on.
These are great shows, but often there is more certainty about a suspect than in real life. As long as one keeps in mind what TV is about, and what im important to a producer is the creation of entertainment that sustains viewing figures. Truth is somewhat secondary, though TV shows that enthral us most tend to at least attempt some credibility.
Great question
According to studies: Criminal profiling is more than 60% accurate. But it is not as effective as they show in T.V shows.
Here is an article link. I hope it may help you further.
https://www.vox.com/platform/amp/future-perfect/2018/11/12/18044688/criminal-profilers-mindhunter-hannibal-criminal-minds
it's certainly not similar to what you see in TV which is highly dramatized, but to be fair there are MANY occupations that get dramatized on TV that people watch- I think most people know what they're watching isn't an accurate depiction and do some of their own research.